For help and insights, join Robert for the final Benefact Group webinar of the year ‘A practical introduction to social impact measurement’ on 14 November 2023. The session will run 10:30 – 12:00. Register now. Read more »
Why some people can start and complete new projects and other can’t
Howard McClusky, an educational psychologist, developed the Margin of Power concept to explore the limits of human capacity. He formalised his thinking into three elements Margin, Load and Power.
Load: the demands placed on a person by their family, work, civic duties, and their own ambitions.
- External — tasks of life such as family, career, socio-economic status
- Internal — self-concept, goals, personal expectations
Power: a person’s energy, skill, competence, and integrity. this also includes support from friends and family, society and their employer.
- Physical — strength, stamina, energy, health
- Social — ability to relate to others
- Mental — ability to think, reason
- Economic — money, position, influence
- Skills — what the individual knows how to do
Margin: a measure of the “wiggle room” each person has to complete a meaningful task, that is a surplus of power provides a cushion to handle demands placed
McClusky expressed this formally as
Margin = Load / Power
- Margin can be increased by reducing load or increasing power
- Howard suggests, subsequently, that if values could be assigned to load and power indicators, a resulting Margin of 0.5- 0.8 would provide a cushion to meet the various emergencies of life
It’s a great idea and seems to hold water. My issue with this is how are you supposed to be able to quantify this? It seems quantitative and objective measures are out. That leaves qualitative, self reported and relative measures as the basis for the theory, and we all know where that road leads.